An analysis of categorizing humanity through kohlbergs moral development principles in antigone by s

Kohlberg also portrays that an individual cannot skip any of these stages while progressing to higher stages of moral reasoning Meyer The caring theme is researched as a set of interpretive skills and sensibilities, proclivities and habits, easily observed and verified.

There is little or no commitment to any values or set of believes, no decisions about future occupations or long term goals, and a general lack of direction. We are only women, we cannot fight with men, Antigone! Showing a close affiliation between reasons and emotions, competence motivation and interest principles the pleasure principle, law of effect or reinforcement further bolsters the case.

Since he is not a maturationist, he cannot simply say that the sequence is wired into the genes. He found out that they tend to face different moral issues, and their judgment based on whether they will act negatively or positively is influenced by several factors Cardwell and Cara, Obedience and Punishment Orientation.

Punishment and Obedience Orientation Here, the reasoning that children have is that they will only be punished if they do the wrong thing. Individually or in a small group, ask students to rank them from most important to them to least important. What better fits the military model of human relations glimpsed in the masculinist "state of nature" and social contract myth underlying western ideology?

Ashford and Craig assert that this theory is overly androcentric. Berkowitz --is examining actual dialogues to see if those who become most challenged and involved in the tensions of moral debate are also those who move forward.

Stage 5, in turn, sees the weakness of stage 4; a well-organized society is not necessarily a moral one. Specifically important are the individual's "view of persons" and their "social perspective level", each of which becomes more complex and mature with each advancing stage.

Thus stage 4 subordinates a concern for motives to a wider concern for the society as a whole. Still, with Piaget, it is unclear that the ancient philosophy of moral development and its inclusion within natural development of human personality had been reclaimed.

What suits our reason likely doesn't suit our full range of motivations some stronger than reason that reason, to be reasonable, should take into account.

For example, people at stage 4 can still understand stage 3 arguments, but they now subordinate them to wider considerations.

Critical Analysis: Kohlberg and Piaget's moral dev. theories

This lesson can be extended on subsequent days by having students generate a list of their own solutions or decisions. Faculty find it useful for understanding special problems that students face when confronted with opposing conceptions of fact and value across the curriculum.

Aristotle's approach was more plausible because its natural growth only provided tools and tendencies for able behavior. She describes three stages of moral reasoning.

Heinz Steals the Drug In Europe. Kohlberg came up with the theory based on the ideas generated while he was researching children and adolescents. Stage 2 - Rewards. Justice itself relies heavily upon the notion of sound reasoning based on principles.

A final note about identity issues: Antigone is able to see beyond? The law has overwhelmed society and society? Whatever the right is, for Kohlberg, it must be universally valid across societies a position known as " moral universalism ": No one likes being punished so acting in the right way is not an option here, but a must.

There are internal standards involved in determining right and wrong; however, there is little reflection or personalizing of these standards. So he told Joe to give him the money he had saved from the paper route. He did not go immediately to college, but instead went to help the Israeli cause, in which he was made the Second Engineer on an old freighter carrying refugees from parts of Europe to Israel.In Sophocles?

play, Antigone, characters illustrate Kohlberg?s moral development principles.

Kohlberg’s Theory of Moral Development

Ismene embodies Kohlberg?s pre-conventional stage throughout Sophocles?s play Antigone. In Kohlberg?s first level of moral thinking, physical consequences of an action determine its goodness or badness regardless of the humane meaning or value. Recent philosophical history gave a rare nod to moral development through Rawls's moreover, that difficulties faced in applying moral principles to socio-moral issues are worth the effort, and should turn out surmountable with effort.

(in logical, social, moral categories) Kohlberg and colleagues looked for patterns.

Lawrence Kohlberg's stages of moral development

They were. Kohlberg has focused on moral development and has proposed a stage theory of moral thinking which goes well beyond Piaget's initial formulations. Kohlberg, who was born ingrew up in Bronxville, New York, and attended the Andover Academy in Massachusetts, a private high school for bright and usually wealthy students.

Moral Development

In Sophocles' play, Antigone, characters illustrate Kohlberg's moral development principles. Ismene embodies Kohlberg's pre-conventional stage throughout Sophocles's play Antigone.

In Kohlberg's first level of moral thinking, physical consequences of an action determine its goodness or badness regardless of the humane meaning or value of these. Moral Development According to Life Span (), moral development requires a complex interweaving of emotions, cognitions, and behaviors (Broderick & Blewitt,p.

). There are two major theories of moral development: Piaget's and Kohlberg's. Kohlberg's stages of moral development and criticisms Understanding the stages of moral development should help in developing or improving upon one’s morals or values.

This is especially true if the characteristics of highly moral people are clearly described.

An analysis of categorizing humanity through kohlbergs moral development principles in antigone by s
Rated 3/5 based on 2 review